Facebook Twitter Instagram Pinterest YouTube Tumblr LinkedIn RSS
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Contribute
    • Donate
    • Forum
    • Contact
    Login
    InfoStride NewsInfoStride News
    • Home
    • Business
    • Celebrity
    • Crime
    • Nigeria
    • Politics
    • Sports
    • Technology
    • More
      • COVID-19
      • Editor’s Picks
      • Health
      • Opinions
      • Press Releases
      • World
    Subscribe
    InfoStride NewsInfoStride News
    Home»Business Matters»Six Strikes Copyright Alert System Can’t Be The Future of Copyright Enforcemen

    Six Strikes Copyright Alert System Can’t Be The Future of Copyright Enforcemen

    Business Matters By EFFSourceJun 3, 2014Updated:Sep 4, 2021No Comments4 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email Reddit VKontakte

    Last week, the group behind the copyright monitoring and enforcement system commonly known as “Six Strikes” released some data about its operations for the first time.

    The Center for Copyright Information (CCI), a group created and funded by major movie studios, music labels, and Internet service providers revealed that their Copyright Alert System (CAS) sent more than 1.3 million accusations of copyright infringement to about 722,000 Internet subscribers. The report also said that over 60,000 of those subscribers received some kind of penalty from their ISP.

    Major media companies and their friends in Congress and the executive branch have been touting CAS as the exemplar of “voluntary” agreements among the Internet’s corporate gatekeepers to reduce infringement. They are encouraging other gatekeepers like advertising networks and payment processors to follow the lead of CAS. And the people behind CAS claim to be educating the public about copyright. So public understanding of what CAS is actually doing and what messages it’s sending are vitally important. That’s why releasing some data about the system is a positive development.

    Some key information is conspicuously missing, though: the actual penalties (called “mitigation measures”) that have been imposed on Internet subscribers, and the contents of the “educational” messages sent to those subscribers.

    We’ve seen some partial and anecdotal information about what the “mitigation measures” might be. CCI insists that Internet accounts are never terminated under this program. Comcast’s website explains that “If a consumer fails to respond to several Copyright Alerts, Comcast will place a persistent alert in any web browser under that account until the account holder contacts Comcast’s Customer Security Assurance professionals to discuss and help resolve the matter.”1 Cablevision’s Optimum Internet service “may temporarily suspend your Internet access for a set period of time” after several Copyright Alerts.2 And a Time Warner Cable executive stated that his company “will restrict users’ Internet browsing by directing them to a landing page.”3 Other ISPs described slowing down users’ connections.

    See also  Self-Driving Cars an $87 Billion Opportunity in 2030, Though None Reach Full Autonomy

    Given these reports, we can presume that some of the 60,477 Internet subscribers who received “mitigation measures” in the past year were in fact kicked off the Internet for some period of time, and others had some or all of their Web requests redirected, making normal Internet use impossible until the penalty was lifted. But we don’t know how many people received each kind of penalty, how long the penalties actually lasted, nor how much their Internet use was inhibited while the penalty was in effect. This is crucial information that should have been included in the CAS report. We’re concerned that these measures could block or interfere with Internet-connected devices that don’t contain standard Web browsers, including vital services that use the Internet such as IP telephone service and burglar alarm monitoring. Without knowing the actual impact of the “mitigation measures” on those who received them, it’s hard for the public to gauge the impact of the CAS program.

    The report also doesn’t give us the text of the alerts or the substance of the copyright “education” that receivers of multiple notices have to complete to get their Internet access back. Again, there are some materials made public on the ISPs’ websites and some reported by anonymous sources. But since CCI and its backers are promoting the system as educational, it’s imperative that the public be able to see and discuss the “educational” materials that ISPs present to subscribers under duress while suspending normal Internet access.

    See also  Wakefield and District Housing at home with IGEL for Virtual Desktop Infrastructure

    We have reasons to be concerned. A draft elementary school curriculum developed in part by CCI presented a biased and incomplete picture of copyright law. And CCI’s website, as well as some of the Copyright Alert notices made public thus far, largely direct those accused of infringement to the video-on-demand and pay-per-view offerings of the six major ISPs that are part of CCI. Another page linked from many of CCI’s materials contains a list of streaming video sites, many of which require a cable or satellite pay-TV subscription from one of CCI’s member companies. So these “educational” messages contain a major commercial component that advances the financial interests of CCI’s backers. There’s nothing wrong with ISPs advertising their own pay-TV services, but it’s disingenuous to call these commercial messages educational.

    In short, it’s good that this private, government-encouraged program is moving towards greater transparency, but it needs to go further by disclosing the impact of its “mitigation measures” on Internet users and the full content of its “educational” messages. If private agreements are going to be the future of copyright enforcement on the Internet, they must be transparent and accountable to the public.

    • 1. http://customer.comcast.com/help-and-support/internet/mitigation-measures
    • 2. http://optimum.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/3592/kw/copyright
    • 3. https://torrentfreak.com/verizon-will-reduce-speeds-of-repeated-bittorrent-pirates-121115/

    Source: Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) – eff.org

    Support InfoStride News' Credible Journalism: Only credible journalism can guarantee a fair, accountable and transparent society, including democracy and government. It involves a lot of efforts and money. We need your support. Click here to Donate

    Copyright Digital Media EFF EFF News Electronic Frontier Foundation Press Release Technology News
    Share. Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Pinterest Reddit Tumblr VKontakte Email LinkedIn

    Related Posts

    2023 Elections: Agbakoba writes INEC Chairman on the Interpretation of Section 134 of the Nigeria’s Constitution

    Jan 18, 2023

    OPC distances itself from Ojota Crisis, demands Freedom for kidnapped Edo Train Passengers

    Jan 9, 2023

    Five Ways To Analyze The Forex Market

    Dec 22, 2022

    The Scope Of EFCC Powers Will Be Tested By The Courts – Dr Olisa Agbakoba

    Dec 20, 2022
    Add A Comment

    Comments are closed.

    Get Social with Us
    • Facebook
    • Twitter 6.5K
    • Pinterest 93
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    Latest Posts

    Banks Don’t Have New Naira, Money Changers Are Taking Advantage – Whitemoney

    Jan 31, 2023

    Robertson Is Right To Say Liverpool’s Struggles Keep Getting Worse – Richard Keys

    Jan 31, 2023

    Secure Yourself As A Nigerian, Security Agencies Won’t – Leo DaSilva

    Jan 31, 2023

    Naby Keita And Oxlade-Chamberlain Don’t Deserve New Contracts – Dietmar Hamann

    Jan 31, 2023

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest breaking news straight into your inbox!

    Random News

    Kashim Shettima Should Promote Unity Through Sport – BSFA

    Nov 13, 2016

    Assistance to Migrants Rescued at Sea in Tunisia

    Jun 20, 2015

    The Stabbing Of Buhari’s Supporter In Delta Is A Babaric Act – Ovie Omo-Agege

    Sep 15, 2019

    Vine Begins Allowing Users to Reserve Vanity Names

    Dec 21, 2013

    InfoStride News delivers the latest breaking news, Nigeria news, world news and top stories on business, celebrity, entertainment, politics, sports, technology and more. Experience the best of in-depth coverage, special reports, football highlights, political opinions, crime watch, celebrity gossips etc.

    GooglePlay Store Button

    Support InfoStride News' Credible Journalism

    Credible journalism involves a lot of efforts and money; and can guarantee a fair, accountable and transparent society, including democracy and government. We need your support to continue offering free access to our loyal readers and visitors like you.

    Click here to Donate

    Facebook Twitter Instagram Pinterest YouTube Tumblr LinkedIn RSS
    • Our Terms
    © 2023 InfoStride News. All Rights Reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Sign In or Register

    Welcome Back!

    Login to your account below.

    Continue with Facebook
    Continue with Google
    Continue with Twitter
    Lost password?